Market Analysis, Market insights
16/09/2025

Michaël Nizard, Head of Multi-Asset & Overlay 

A symbolic downgrade

On Friday, September 12, Fitch downgraded France's sovereign rating from AA- to A+. The agency justified this decision on the grounds of a persistent deficit, public debt already at 114% of GDP and likely to reach 132% in 2034, and chronic political instability. At this level, France is approaching Italy's ratios, which are expected to reach 135%, while diverging from economies such as Spain and Belgium, whose trajectories appear more stable. This downgrade does not place France in a situation of immediate crisis, but it confirms the perception of relative weakness.

This downgrade can also be explained by the continuing deterioration in budgetary balances. Since 2017, tax revenues have fallen by 1.6 percentage points of GDP for households and 0.8 percentage points for businesses, without being offset by a reduction in public spending. Public spending remains high, representing 57% of GDP compared with an average of 50% in the eurozone, a level comparable to that of 2017 after peaking during the pandemic. The primary deficit remains below the threshold for stabilizing debt. An analysis of the spending surplus compared to the rest of the eurozone (7 percentage points of GDP) shows that most of it comes from the pension system (2.2 percentage points) and healthcare (1.5 percentage points).

But a sanction set to last with the political crisis

The problem lies in the fact that this sanction seems set to continue. After the fall of the Bayrou government and the arrival of Sébastien Lecornu at Matignon, the parliamentary deadlock persists. In the absence of a solid majority, the prospect of the dissolution of the National Assembly appears increasingly inevitable. The inability to build a credible consensus around the budget reinforces the idea that France will not return to a clear consolidation path anytime soon. These institutional weaknesses fuel the perception of France as a peripheral country within the eurozone, rather than a semi-core pillar.

Interest rates rising, but still contained

Bond markets are reflecting this downgrade without panicking. The yield on ten-year French government bonds (OATs) is around 3.5%, slightly above Greece and close to Italy. The rise in borrowing costs reflects an increased risk premium, but remains well below the levels seen during the sovereign debt crisis. French debt continues to be considered good quality by most investors.
The most notable development does not concern the ten-year yield, but rather the widening spread with thirty-year bonds, reflecting a steepening curve that is often interpreted as a sign of inflationary concerns. However, long-term expectations have remained stable. This movement mainly reflects technical factors: a structural reduction in demand from pension funds and insurers, demographic dynamics reducing the need for very long-term securities, and market saturation due to sovereign bond issues. Investors have tended to favor steepener trades to position themselves on the spread between five-year and 30-year yields, taking into account all of these technical factors, which affect all sovereign debt (US, UK, German), and also expressing their doubts about France's fiscal trajectory. In this context, where safe-haven assets are under pressure, flows are shifting towards gold and even investment-grade credit, which remains in demand despite its credit spread reaching historically low levels.

Indeed, a major shift is taking place in the debt market hierarchy: several large French groups, including LVMH, Airbus, L'Oréal, and Axa, are now borrowing at lower rates than the government. The contrast highlights both the confidence placed in these companies and the pressure exerted on sovereign debt by excess supply and the massive volume of public debt issued.

Points of resilience

This picture needs to be qualified. France has several strengths: a current account balance that is close to equilibrium, in contrast to the massive deficits of Greece and Spain before 2008; a high household savings rate of 19%, which provides a solid domestic cushion; lower inflation than in its neighbors; and the ECB's safety net, via its Transitional Protection Program (TPI), designed to prevent excessive fragmentation of the eurozone.
It should also be remembered that the risk of contagion to the rest of the eurozone remains very limited. France's problem is primarily political, not financial: France is not a bankrupt state likely to drag down its neighbors. Even if the National Rally wins, the impact would remain limited due to the probable absence of an absolute majority and European safeguards. The Italian example shows that spreads can remain orderly despite the arrival of a government perceived as radical. Finally, the mere mention of the ESM by the ECB would probably be enough to calm any excessive tension on spreads.

A shift towards a sustainable risk premium

Fitch estimates that the deficit will exceed 5% of GDP until 2027, pushing any consolidation until after the presidential election. This trajectory is already largely priced in by the markets. France is losing its status as a semi-core pillar and is now considered peripheral in the eurozone. However, it is not entering a crisis zone. The higher risk premium is now the new normal, absorbed by investors in a context where credit and alternative assets continue to attract massive flows. It is indeed the risk of a new dissolution that will once again weigh on French debt.

DISCLAIMER

This is a marketing communication.
15/09/2025
This document is issued by the Edmond de Rothschild Group. It is not legally binding and is intended solely for information purposes. This document may not be communicated to persons located in jurisdictions in which it would be considered as a recommendation, an offer of products or services or a solicitation, and in which case its communication could be in breach of applicable laws and regulations. This document has not been reviewed or approved by a regulator of any jurisdiction. The figures, comments, opinions and/or analyses contained herein reflect the sentiment of the Edmond de Rothschild Group with respect to market trends based on its expertise, economic analyses and the information in its possession at the date on which this document was drawn up and may change at any time without notice. They may no longer be accurate or relevant at the time of reading, owing notably to the publication date of the document or to changes on the market. This document is intended solely to provide general and introductory information to the readers, and notably should not be used as a basis for any decision to buy, sell or hold an investment. Under no circumstances may the Edmond de Rothschild Group be held liable for any decision to invest, divest or hold an investment taken on the basis of these comments and analyses. The Edmond de Rothschild Group therefore recommends that investors obtain the various regulatory descriptions of each financial product before investing, to analyse the risks involved and form their own opinion independently of the Edmond de Rothschild Group. Investors are advised to seek independent advice from specialist advisors before concluding any transactions based on the information contained in this document, notably in order to ensure the suitability of the investment with their financial and tax situation. Past performance and volatility are not a reliable indicator of future performance and volatility and may vary over time, and may be independently affected by exchange rate fluctuations.
Source of the information: unless otherwise stated, the sources used in the present document are those of the Edmond de Rothschild Group. This document and its content may not be reproduced or used in whole or in part without the permission of the Edmond de Rothschild Group.
Copyright © Edmond de Rothschild Group – All rights reserved
EDMOND DE ROTHSCHILD ASSET MANAGEMENT (FRANCE) 
47, rue du Faubourg Saint-Honoré 75401 Paris Cedex 08 
Société anonyme governed by an executive board and a supervisory board with capital of 11.033.769 euros 
AMF Registration number GP 04000015 
332.652.536 R.C.S. Paris

Download Fitch Rating EN Download Fitch Rating FR